What Should GM Jim Hendry & the Cubs Do with Closer Carlos Marmol & Starter Matt Garza? — Wrigley Field 2/2/11

Posted on 02 February 2011 by Lou

What will the Cubs and General Manager Jim Hendry do with Closer Carlos Marmol and Starter Matt Garza.

Marmol has emerged as a reliable and dependable closer.  He has 2 years of arbitration left.  Marmol is seeking $5.6 million for the 2011 MLB season, while the Cubs have offered $4.1 million.  Will the 2 sides meet in the middle or will the case go to arbitration?  Or could we see the 2 sides agree to a long-term deal that locks in Marmol as the Cubs closer for 3 or 4 years down the line.  A 3-year, $20 million deal or a 4-year, $30 million deal could make both sides happy.  The Cubs would get a little discount while Marmol would get some added security given the fact that he as averaged almost 80 appearances over the last 3 seasons.  That is a lot of mileage on one pitcher’s arm.

The Cubs face a similar dilemma with Garza, although, Garza still has 3 years of arbitration left.  Plus, Garza has yet to pitch in a Cubs uniform, so it might be nice to wait a year to make sure both sides are happy before entertaining long-term contract talks.  Garza and the Cubs agreed upon a $5.9 million deal for the 2011 MLB schedule.  If he keeps winning 15 games and racking up 200 innings pitched, he would likely command $10 million in 2012 and a little more than that in 2013 (his last 2 years of arbitration).  Will the sides try to come to terms on a long-term 4-5 year deal?  It would be in both sides’ best interests, but again, it will come down to dollars.  I have a feeling that the Cubs will hold off on Garza until they see how he handles the pressure in Chicago where fans have long-suffered without a World Series title for way too long.

We’ll keep you posted on either front as soon as anything happens…

Advertise Here

Photos from our Flickr stream

See all photos

Advertise Here